This post contains affiliate links. We may earn money from the products mentioned in this post, but this is at no cost to you
Easy MnM cookie ice cream sandwiches. Consisting of creamy ice cream nestled between two MnM cookies, covered with sprinkles, chocolate or other favorite toppings.
This is the perfect way to enjoy two desserts in one and will become a family favorite. Perfect for parties or family treats. Simply choose your favorite ice cream and topping and whip up a batch with the family.
They are delicious and incredibly easy to make.
Related articles:
- The Most Amazing Easy Chocolate Cookie Bars Recipe
- The Best Triple Choc Cookies And Cream Ice Cream Cake
Love ice cream and cookies?
Put them together and you have a match made in heaven. Cookie ice cream sandwiches are incredibly easy to make, they taste delicious and the kids (and big kids) will absolutely love them.
Perfect for a hot summer’s day or for handing out at parties.
If you are looking for a party activity, kids would love being creative and making their own. Simply have several toppings available so the kids can choose their favorite.
Everyone will have a lot of fun making and then eating them!
Ingredients You Will Need
There are a few ingredients that you will need to make the cookie ice cream sandwiches.
- Half Gallon Vanilla Ice Cream
- 16 Store-bought MnM’s cookies
- Mini chocolate chips
- Coconut flakes
- Sliced almonds
- Walnut pieces
- Sprinkles
These MnM cookie ice cream sandwiches are made using store bought cookies, which makes them even easier and quicker to prepare.
Bake your own cookies if you prefer, but store bought ones will work a treat!
The easiest way to create the ice cream sandwiches is to have all your ingredients laid out into separate bowls before you start.
This will enable easy access to everything you need and make the process super smooth.
Use Good Quality Ice Cream!
One of the tricks to ensure you create THE best cookie ice cream sandwich is to use a good quality ice cream!
If you are going to go to the trouble of making your own ice cream sandwiches then you want them to taste absolutely amazing!
Be sure to use your favorite ice cream, but as a minimum ensure that it is creamy and bursting with flavor.
6 Steps To The Easiest MnM Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches
Making cookie ice cream sandwiches is actually incredibly easy. They look really fancy, but the reality is they are one of the easiest treats you can make.
They will only take 10 minutes to make, and then as long as your patience lasts whilst they freeze!
Follow these simple 6 steps to the most amazing dessert! (Scroll down for the full recipe card).
Step 1: Freeze The Cookies
Before you start, ensure that the cookies have been in the freezer to make them hard. Ensure that you do this for freshly baked and store bought cookies.
Step 2: Scoop The Ice Cream
Turn the cookie upside down and place one generous ice cream scoop on the top. This should be sitting on the flat side of the cookie.
Use the scoop to gently push the ice cream to the edges.
Step 3: Add Another Cookie
To create the ice cream sandwich you need to place another cookie on the top of the ice cream. Again ensure that the flat side of the cookie presses against the ice cream.
Press down gently in the center of the cookie. Don’t press too hard otherwise the cookie might break!
Step 4: Tidy The Ice Cream
Using a flat knife or a spatula, gently smooth the edges of the ice cream all the way around the cookie.
Step 5: Decorate!
Now is the fun part. It’s time to decorate your ice cream sandwich.
Simply choose your favorite topping and gently roll the edges of the ice cream into it.
If the topping has trouble sticking, gently press it in place.
Step 6: Freeze The Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich
Once the cookie ice cream sandwiches have been made, place each individual cookie onto a piece of parchment paper.
Place it into the freezer for 20minutes to ensure it’s hard.
It’s then ready to eat!
Do I Need To Freeze The Cookies First?
The simple answer to this is YES!
The cookies that are used to create an ice cream sandwich need to be sturdy. This allows them to hold the ice cream in place without them bending. This is why they must be placed in the freezer.
If you have freshly baked the cookies, then allow them to completely cool before adding them to the freezer.
If however you are using store bought cookies, they can go straight into the freezer.
Want to skip this part and just whack that ice cream between the cookies? Give it a try and you will end up with a crumbly ice cream mess!
It’s definitely NOT how you want to enjoy your amazing MnM’s cookie ice cream sandwiches!
Tips To Storing and Freezing Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches
Let’s pretend here for a minute that you are not actually going to eat ALL of these delicious MnM’s cookie ice cream sandwiches.
If you want to store the ice cream sandwiches in the freezer, you can certainly do that, but you will need to do a bit of prep first. Use these tips to make it super easy.
- Wrap tightly: Each individual cookie ice cream sandwich will need to be wrapped in a piece of parchment paper. They can then be placed tightly together in a freezer bag.
- Freeze straight away: When creating the ice cream sandwiches, wrap them and place in the freezer as soon as they are finished. Don’t wait to finish the entire batch before placing in the freezer otherwise they will start to melt!
- Freeze for at least 20 minutes: Freeze the ice cream sandwiches for at least 20 minutes, but the longer the better. They can then be stored in the freezer for several weeks.
Recipe Tips & Variations
- Place cookies in the freezer before attempting to make the sandwiches, to ensure that they are hard.
- If you notice that the ice cream is melting whilst making them, place both the ice cream and sandwiches back into the freezer.
- Use smaller cookies to create smaller ice cream sandwiches.
- Change up the taste of the ice cream sandwiches by using different flavor cookies. Mix it up, experiment and have some fun!
- Create holiday ice cream sandwiches by changing the toppings. For example use red sprinkles at Christmas, orange at Halloween or red, white and blue for a 4th of July treat.
Topping Variations
There are several toppings that you can add to ice cream sandwiches including:
- Nuts
- Dried Fruit
- Sprinkles or 100’s and 1,000’s
- Crumbled cookies
- Coconut
- Edible flowers
- Crushed candy
- Mini marshmallows
- Mini MnM’s
- Chopped up Mars or Snickers bars
So there you have it. The perfect summer or party treat that your know everyone is going to LOVE. Simple to make, great to look at and delicious to eat.
Choose your favorite ice cream and topping and make them your own.
MnM Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches Recipe
MnM Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches
Easy MnM cookie ice cream sandwiches. Consisting of creamy ice cream nestled between two MnM cookies, covered with sprinkles, chocolate or other favorite toppings.
Perfect for parties or family treats. They are delicious and incredibly easy to make.
Ingredients
- Half Gallon Vanilla Ice Cream
- 16 Store-bought MnM’s cookies
- Mini chocolate chips
- Coconut flakes
- Sliced almonds
- Walnut pieces
- Sprinkles
Instructions
- Prepare all ingredients into separate bowls
- Place cookies into the freezer to harden
- Once ready to begin, turn a cookie upside down and place a scoop of ice cream on the top.
- Place another cookie directly on top of the ice cream (flat side touching the ice cream) and press down gently in the middle of the cookie.
- Using a knife or spatula, even off the ice cream around the edges of the sandwich.
- Roll the ice cream sides into a topping of your choice
- If the toppings don't stick, gently press them in place with your fingers
- Place the ice cream sandwich onto a cookie sheet that is covered with parchment paper
- Place into the freezer for at least 30minutes to harden. The longer they are in the freezer the better
- When ready to eat, leave on a plate at room temperature for a few minutes to allow the cookie to slightly soften.
Notes
- If the ice cream starts to melt whilst making the sandwiches, place both the ice cream and the partially made ice cream sandwiches back into the freezer.
- It is a good idea to place the ice cream sandwich into the freezer as soon as they are made rather than completing batches first.
- Ice cream sandwiches can be stored in the freezer for a few weeks.
- Ensure that each sandwich is wrapped in parchment paper and then placed into a freezer storage bag.
- Mix up the taste by using different flavor cookies.
- There are numerous topping flavors that can be used including: Nuts, Dried Fruit, Sprinkles or 100’s and 1,000’s, Crumbled cookies, Coconut, Edible flowers, Crushed candy, Mini marshmallows, Mini MnM’s, Chopped up Mars or Snickers bars.
Need some more recipe ideas? Check out our entire range of party food ideas that are perfect for the kids and adults too. There are plenty of homemade birthday cakes, cupcakes, cookies, chocolate popcorn and other delicious recipes that guests will all love.
Let’s stay in touch. Do you love these super easy MnM cookie ice cream sandwiches? Sign up to the newsletter to receive weekly updates for easy party ideas including recipes, decorations and party themes. You will also have access to a ton of free printable’s.
Leave a Reply